Best Bagels in NYC

Best Bagels in NYC: 18 Shops Ranked by Someone Who Eats Them Weekly

The best bagels in NYC come from Ess-a-Bagel, Apollo Bagels, Utopia Bagels and Kossar’s, with Russ & Daughters holding the title for what goes on top rather than the bagel itself — and the single most-recommended shop in every older guide, Absolute Bagels, has been closed since December 2024 and now operates under a different name and different ownership. That last part matters, because most lists you’ll find still send you to a shop that no longer exists as it was.

I’ve been eating my way through this city’s bagels for eleven years, mostly at 7:40am before work, mostly standing up. What I’ve learned is that the argument about the best bagels in NYC is less about ranking than about freshness windows. A great bagel is a 90-minute object, and any ranking of the best bagels in NYC that ignores the clock is ranking the wrong thing. The same bagel at 7am and 2pm is two different foods, and half the disappointment people report comes from showing up at the wrong hour rather than the wrong shop.

So this guide gives you eighteen of the best bagel shops in NYC, each with an address, what to order, and — where it matters — what time to be there. Then it tells you the truth about the water, which is where most writing about the top bagels in NYC goes wrong.

Quick Answer: The Best Bagels in NYC

If you wantGo toWhereOrder
The benchmarkEss-a-Bagel831 Third Ave, Midtown EastEverything, scallion cream cheese
The new standardApollo Bagels242 E 10th St, East VillageSesame, plain schmear. Go early
Hand-rolled, old-schoolUtopia Bagels19-11 Utopia Pkwy, WhitestoneEverything, hand-rolled
The appetizing experienceRuss & Daughters179 E Houston St, LESSuper Heebster, or lox on plain
A bialy, properlyKossar’s367 Grand St, LESOnion bialy. Not a bagel, better
Brooklyn’s bestBagel Hole400 Seventh Ave, Park SlopePlain, small, dense
HarlemBO’s Bagels2 W 116th StEverything with bacon, egg, cheese
The history lessonZabar’s2245 Broadway at 80thBagel, Nova, and a browse

If you get one bagel on one morning and want the shortest path to the best bagels in NYC: Ess-a-Bagel on Third Avenue, before 9am, everything bagel, scallion cream cheese, do not let them toast it.

First, the Thing Every Other Guide Gets Wrong: Absolute Bagels

Absolute Bagels at 2788 Broadway was shut down by the New York City Health Department in December 2024 after an inspection logged 67 violations, including evidence of rats and live roaches. It had been, for about two decades, the most frequently named answer to the question of the best bagels in New York City — a cash-only Thai-family-run shop near Columbia with a permanent line out the door.

Here’s the full sequence, because it’s confusing and almost every list of the best bagel shops in NYC still has it wrong:

  • December 12–13, 2024 — the Health Department ordered it closed. Staff were seen clearing out equipment. Workers and a building broker said it was permanent.
  • Late December 2025 — the same storefront reopened as New Absolute Bagels, under a new owner, Kyung Mi Kim. Much of the original staff came back. Customers reported the recipe tasted unchanged — one longtime regular said the egg bagel was “pretty much like the original.” The cash-only policy was dropped.
  • March 2026 — the shop was renamed 2788 Bagels, reportedly over legal concerns about using the Absolute name.

So: the storefront at 2788 Broadway, between West 107th and 108th, is open and selling bagels made by many of the same hands. It is not Absolute Bagels and the owners aren’t allowed to call it that. Whether it belongs on a list of the top bagels in NYC is genuinely unsettled — the people I trust are split, and it’s been under its current name for about six months. Go, decide for yourself, and don’t let an old blog post tell you it’s the Absolute you remember.

Best Bagels in NYC: The Manhattan List

Best Bagels in NYC: The Manhattan List

1. Ess-a-Bagel — 831 Third Avenue (and 359 First Avenue)

The benchmark against which everything else gets measured, open since 1976. Big, glossy, properly chewy, with a crust that gives before it tears — the template for what most people picture when they think of the best bagels in New York City. The cream cheese is applied in a quantity that first-timers find alarming and then come to require. Scallion is the correct choice; vegetable is the sensible one. If a single shop has to stand for the best bagels in NYC, it’s this one.

Two things to know. First, Ess-a-Bagel has historically enforced a no-toasting policy — a fresh New York bagel is not supposed to be toasted, and asking will mark you out. Second, the Midtown East line at 8:30am on a weekday is long and moves fast; the First Avenue location is calmer.

2. Apollo Bagels — 242 East 10th Street, East Village (and 73 Greenwich Avenue, West Village)

The best bagel opened in the last decade, and the reason the conversation about the best bagels in NYC has reopened at all. Apollo describes itself as “a new-school bagel shop rooted in old-school technique,” which in practice means naturally fermented dough, boiled, and baked fresh every morning. The crust blisters. The interior is tighter and less bready than the 1970s shops, and it has forced every older name on this list of the best bagels in NYC to defend itself.

The catch is supply, and it’s the one real drawback among the best bagel shops in NYC at the top end. Apollo runs out, routinely, and the line forms before opening on weekends. Get there in the first hour or accept that you’re gambling. Sesame is the one.

3. Russ & Daughters — 179 East Houston Street, Lower East Side

Not the best bagel in the city, and the best thing you can eat on one. Joel Russ, who came to Manhattan around 1905 from Strzyżów in Poland, started with a pushcart of Polish mushrooms, added pickled herring, and opened J Russ International Appetizers in 1914. The shop has been at 179 East Houston since 1920. It is an appetizing store — the specific Jewish American institution that sells the dairy-and-fish half of a kosher kitchen, which is why you buy lox here and pastrami somewhere else.

This counter is where most people’s idea of the best bagels in New York City actually comes from, even though the bagel is incidental to it. Order the Super Heebster (whitefish and baked salmon salad, horseradish-dill cream cheese, wasabi roe) or keep it plain: a plain bagel, cream cheese, hand-sliced Gaspé Nova. Russ & Daughters also has a Hudson Yards location that opened in July 2023, plus the Orchard Street café around the corner from the original.

This is the stop I’d defend hardest on any list of the best bagels in New York City, even though the bagel is the least interesting part of it.

Russ & Daughters — 179 East Houston Street, Lower East Side

4. Kossar’s Bagels & Bialys — 367 Grand Street, Lower East Side

Open since 1936, and the best bialy in the United States. A bialy isn’t a bagel — no hole, no boiling, a depression in the middle filled with onion and sometimes poppy seed, baked dry and chewy. It comes from Białystok in Poland, the community that made it was largely destroyed in the Holocaust, and Kossar’s on Grand Street is one of the last places making them properly.

The bagels are very good. The bialy is the reason to go, and it’s the one item on this page that no roundup of the best bagels in New York City ever bothers to explain. Kossar’s now has Upper East Side, Upper West Side, Hudson Yards and West End Avenue locations, but Grand Street is the original.

5. Tompkins Square Bagels — 165 Avenue A, East Village

The house-made cream cheese shop, founded in the East Village in 2011. Dozens of flavours, which sounds like a gimmick and mostly isn’t — the scallion is excellent and the sweeter ones have their constituency. Bagels are solid rather than transcendent; you come for the schmear selection. It’s the best NYC bagels shop for anyone who cares more about what’s on top than underneath.

Five locations now: 165 Avenue A, 1159 Third Avenue (opens 6:30am, the earliest), 184 Second Avenue, 23 East 17th Street, and 424 Fifth Avenue. Among the best bagel shops in NYC for anyone who wants to try six cream cheeses in one sitting.

6. H&H Bagels — Upper East Side, Upper West Side, Moynihan Train Hall

A real New York story: founded 1972, collapsed completely, came back. Helmer Toro and his brother-in-law Hector Hernandez bought Midtown Bagels at Broadway and 80th Street in 1972 and combined their surnames. The company went bankrupt in 1979, recovered, and then came apart properly between 2011 and 2012 — tax fraud charges against Toro, the New Jersey plant auctioned off, the original West 80th Street store closed by city marshals, and eviction from the last site.

H&H was rebuilt from 2014 under new management and now runs five New York locations — Upper East Side, Upper West Side, JFK, LaGuardia and Moynihan Train Hall — with a franchise programme and a Queens bakery. The bagel is bigger and softer than the old one. It’s reliable, it’s everywhere useful, and the best NYC bagels purists are sniffy about it. Moynihan Train Hall makes it the best bagel you can get within 200 feet of a train, which is a narrow category and a genuinely useful one.

7. Murray’s Bagels — 500 Avenue of the Americas, Greenwich Village

Opened November 1996 and the Greenwich Village institution on this list. Dense, chewy, old-school in the right way, and a fixture of the best NYC bagels conversation since the nineties. Murray’s is one of the shops historically known for refusing to toast a fresh bagel — a policy that reads as rudeness to visitors and as quality control to everyone else.

Sixth Avenue between 12th and 13th. Good for a bagel to eat while walking into Washington Square, and one of the few best bagel shops in NYC with a genuine Village pedigree.

Murray's Bagels — 500 Avenue of the Americas, Greenwich Village

8. 2788 Bagels — 2788 Broadway, Upper West Side

The former Absolute, under new ownership since late 2025 and this name since March 2026. Covered in full above. Worth your own verdict rather than anyone else’s.

9. Tal Bagels — Upper East Side

The Upper East Side’s workhorse, and better than its lack of reputation suggests. Big bagels, a long appetizing counter, a room full of people who have been coming for thirty years. Not a destination; a very good local. Every neighbourhood should have one and most of them don’t, which is its own comment on where the best bagels in NYC actually get eaten.

10. David’s Bagels — First Avenue, East Village / Gramercy

Small shop, serious chew, no interest in being on a list. The bagels are tight-crumbed and genuinely hard to improve on. It’s one of the quiet answers when New Yorkers argue about the best NYC bagels and someone wants to end the conversation.

11. Bagel Bob’s — University Place, Greenwich Village

NYU’s bagel, cheap and open early. Not in the top tier and it isn’t pretending to be. Useful to know about if you’re near Washington Square at 7am.

Best Bagel Shops in NYC: Brooklyn

Brooklyn’s bagel scene is smaller than its pizza scene and the top of it is excellent. Four of the best bagel shops in NYC sit within a few subway stops of each other here.

12. Bagel Hole — 400 Seventh Avenue, Park Slope

The most purist bagel in the five boroughs, and the smallest. No frills, no sandwich menu worth discussing, no decor. A dense, properly small bagel with a tight crumb and real chew — closer to what a 1960s New York bagel actually was, before they inflated. The New York–style bagel grew from about 3 ounces in 1915 to roughly 6 ounces by 2003, and Bagel Hole is the argument against that trend.

Order a plain, eat it with nothing. It is the most austere entry on any list of the best bagels in NYC and the one I’d hand a sceptic first.

13. Terrace Bagels — 222 Prospect Park West, Park Slope

Windsor Terrace’s shop, open 7am to 4pm, seven days. Large, chewy, unfussy, and a fixture of the Prospect Park morning. Terrace is the one Park Slope parents carry home in a paper sack on a Saturday, and the sesame is the pick. Firmly among the best bagel shops in NYC for a weekend walk-up.

14. Bagel Joint — Greenpoint

Greenpoint’s entry, and proof the neighbourhood isn’t only Polish bakeries. Solid, generous, open early, and the right stop before a walk down to Transmitter Park. Greenpoint rarely figures in the best NYC bagels debate and this is why it should. Not a pilgrimage — a very good reason not to leave the neighbourhood, and a reminder that the best bagel shops in NYC include a lot of places nobody writes about.

Bagel Joint — Greenpoint

15. Shelsky’s — Brooklyn

An appetizing store with a point of view, and the source of the best line in the water debate. Co-owner Peter Shelsky, asked whether New York City water is what makes the bagels: “It’s not the water. It’s the know-how.” More on that below. The smoked fish counter is the real draw, and the bagels are the correct delivery system for it. Shelsky’s is also the most quotable voice in the whole best NYC bagels argument, for reasons that become clear below.

Top Bagels in NYC: Queens, Harlem and Uptown

The best bagels in NYC are not concentrated below 96th Street, and a surprising amount of the serious baking happens in Queens.

16. Utopia Bagels — 19-11 Utopia Parkway, Whitestone, Queens

Hand-rolled, made “the old-fashioned way,” and the technical high point of the outer boroughs. Among the top bagels in NYC this is the one made most carefully: Utopia rolls by hand rather than by machine, which is now rare enough to be the whole selling proposition, and the difference shows in an irregular, blistered crust that a machine-formed ring never has.

Whitestone is the original and it’s a trek — about an hour from Midtown, which is why the best NYC bagels lists written by Manhattan people tend to leave it off. Utopia has since opened locations in Midtown at 120 East 34th Street, in Long Island City, and on Third Avenue, which means you can now get a hand-rolled Queens bagel without leaving Manhattan. That Midtown address, incidentally, is the honest answer to anyone searching for a good bagel around 34th and Park.

17. BO’s Bagels — 2 West 116th Street, Harlem

Harlem’s own, and the best bagel above 110th Street. BO’s bakes bagels and bialys daily, does a proper bacon-egg-and-cheese, and has the loose, friendly counter energy that the downtown top bagels in NYC destinations have mostly lost. If you’re anywhere near Central Park North, this is your stop.

18. Mike’s Bagels — Washington Heights

Up near Columbia-Presbyterian, feeding hospital shifts around the clock. Unglamorous, consistent, and the only genuinely good bagel for a long way in any direction. The best bagels in NYC are not all downtown, and this shop is the proof furthest north. The kind of shop that never appears on any ranking of the top bagels in NYC and keeps an entire neighbourhood fed.

Also worth knowing in Queens: Between the Bagel in Astoria for a sandwich-forward menu, and Seoul Meets Bagel, which puts bulgogi on a bagel and makes it work far better than it has any right to. Neither will win a purist’s vote in the best NYC bagels stakes. Both are doing something nobody in Manhattan is.

Mike's Bagels — Washington Heights

The Appetizing Stores: Where the Lox Comes From

A thing most guides to the best bagels in New York City miss entirely: the bagel and the fish come from different traditions and usually from different shops.

An appetizing store sells the dairy-and-fish side of a kosher kitchen — smoked salmon, whitefish, sable, herring, cream cheese, babka. A delicatessen sells the meat side. You cannot understand the top bagels in NYC without that distinction, because Jewish dietary law keeps them apart, and that separation is why New York has two distinct kinds of shop that an outsider would merge into one.

StoreWhereWhat to get
Russ & Daughters179 E Houston St, LES; Hudson YardsGaspé Nova, Super Heebster, chopped liver
Zabar’s2245 Broadway at 80thNova, the cheese counter, the housewares floor
Murray’s Sturgeon ShopBroadway, Upper West SideSturgeon, sable, hand-sliced lox
Shelsky’sBrooklynSmoked fish flights, pastrami-cured salmon
Kossar’s367 Grand St, LESBialys, and a counter that knows what it’s doing

Zabar’s deserves a line of its own: a family business running more than ninety years at 80th and Broadway, part food hall and part Upper West Side civic institution. Buy a bag of bagels, a quarter pound of Nova, and then spend twenty minutes upstairs looking at kitchen equipment you don’t need. That’s the correct Zabar’s visit, and it’s a different errand from hunting the best NYC bagels.

The pairing rules, briefly:

  • Plain bagel — the only correct base for lox. Nothing should compete with the fish
  • Everything — cream cheese alone, or with tomato and onion. Not with delicate smoked salmon
  • Sesame — the most versatile. Works with anything
  • Pumpernickel — whitefish salad, or a sharp horseradish cream cheese
  • Egg bagel — on its own, warm, with butter. A different food
  • Salt bagel — plain cream cheese, and be ready for it

Is It the Water? The Honest Answer

No — or rather, the water helps a little and the technique does nearly all of it.

The claim is that New York City tap water, which is low in calcium and magnesium, is soft enough to let gluten develop differently, producing a chewier interior and a crisper crust. There is some real chemistry in that. It is also nowhere near sufficient to explain the difference, and the people who bake for a living mostly say so.

The case against, in their words. Peter Shelsky of Shelsky’s: “It’s not the water. It’s the know-how” — pointing out that New Jersey and Long Island have entirely different water and produce perfectly good New York–style bagels. A Denver baker who went to the trouble of replicating New York’s water chemistry concluded that the traditional process and the oven matter at least as much, and that without the right oven you don’t get the same bagel. The case for still has defenders — one East Village shop owner credits the flavour “100% to the water” — so it isn’t a settled argument among practitioners, just a lopsided one.

What actually makes the best bagels in NYC:

  1. A long, cold fermentation. Overnight at minimum. This is where flavour comes from, and it’s the step industrial producers skip
  2. Hand-rolling. A rolled-and-joined ring has irregular density and blisters; an extruded one doesn’t
  3. Boiling in malted water. Barley malt in the kettle gives the signature leathery skin, the shine, and most of the taste
  4. Baking on wet boards. Traditionally burlap-covered cedar or pine, wetted down, sometimes dusted with cornmeal or semolina. Partway through the bake the baker flips the bagels and pulls the boards out
  5. Selling them within two hours. The single biggest variable, and the one entirely in your control

Point five is why the top bagels in NYC are a function of timing. Any shop on this list at 7:30am beats any shop on this list at 3pm.

The No-Toasting Rule and Other Ordering Etiquette

A fresh New York bagel is not toasted, and several of the best bagel shops in NYC will refuse to do it. Murray’s and Ess-a-Bagel are both known for the policy. Every shop among the top bagels in NYC holds this line to some degree. The logic is straightforward: toasting is a repair for a stale bagel, and asking for it on a bagel that came out of the oven forty minutes ago tells the counter you can’t tell the difference.

If your bagel is a day old, toast it. That’s what toasting is for.

The rest of the counter rules:

  • Know your order before you reach the counter. The line is long and the person behind it is not interested in your deliberation
  • Say it in order: bagel, then toasted-or-not, then spread, then extras. “Everything, not toasted, scallion cream cheese”
  • Don’t ask for it scooped unless you mean it. You can; you’ll be judged; proceed
  • Cash still helps. Several of the older shops were cash-only until recently and some of the smaller ones still are
  • A baker’s dozen is thirteen. If you’re buying a dozen to take home, ask
  • Don’t order a cinnamon-raisin bagel with lox. The sweet flavours arrived in the 1950s and 60s and remain controversial — one traditional verdict on them is shonda, a disgrace
  • “Appetizing” is a noun here. You buy appetizing. It isn’t an adjective

Best Bagels in NYC by Neighborhood

The practical version, for when you’re deciding based on where you already are. Every entry is one of the top bagels in NYC within a short walk of that spot.

Where you areGo toWalk
Midtown EastEss-a-Bagel, 831 Third AveThe benchmark
Midtown / 34th StUtopia Bagels, 120 E 34th StHand-rolled, Queens recipe
Near Times SquareH&H at Moynihan Train Hall, or walk east to UtopiaNothing good is in Times Square
Near Central Park (south)Tal Bagels or H&H, Upper East Side10 minutes from the park
Near Central Park (north)BO’s Bagels, 2 W 116th StBest uptown bagel
Greenwich VillageMurray’s, 500 Sixth Ave; Apollo, 73 Greenwich AveTwo blocks apart
East VillageApollo, 242 E 10th St; Tompkins Square, 165 Ave AApollo first, early
Lower East SideRuss & Daughters; Kossar’s, 367 Grand StDo both. 9 minutes apart
Upper West SideZabar’s, 2245 Broadway; Kossar’s UWS; 2788 BagelsZabar’s for the fish
Park SlopeBagel Hole, 400 Seventh Ave; Terrace, 222 PPWBagel Hole for purists
GreenpointBagel JointBefore the waterfront
AstoriaBetween the Bagel; Seoul Meets BagelSandwich territory
Whitestone, QueensUtopia Bagels, 19-11 Utopia PkwyThe pilgrimage
HarlemBO’s BagelsBialys too
Washington HeightsMike’s BagelsOpen around the clock

On Times Square: there is no good bagel inside it. The honest answer for anyone searching for the best bagels in NYC near Times Square is to walk to Moynihan Train Hall at 33rd and Eighth for H&H, or go four stops downtown. Being near a theatre is not a reason to accept a worse bagel.

Three Bagel Crawls

Split everything. A bagel is 6 ounces and four of them is not a plan.

Three Bagel Crawls

Crawl 1: Lower East Side Appetizing Morning (2 hours, walkable)

  1. Russ & Daughters, 179 East Houston Street — a plain bagel with Gaspé Nova, standing up
  2. Walk nine minutes south to Kossar’s, 367 Grand Street — one onion bialy, no spread
  3. Finish at the Orchard Street café if you want to sit down with coffee

The densest two-stop stretch for the best bagels in New York City, and it doubles as the best short course in Jewish American food in the city.

Crawl 2: East Village to Midtown (3 hours)

  1. Apollo Bagels, 242 East 10th Street — arrive in the first hour, sesame with plain schmear
  2. Tompkins Square Bagels, 165 Avenue A — four minutes’ walk, order three cream cheeses to compare
  3. Walk or take the 6 train to Ess-a-Bagel, 831 Third Avenue — everything, scallion, not toasted

New-school to old-school in one morning, across three of the best bagel shops in NYC. This is the crawl I’d give someone who wants to understand how the best NYC bagels changed in the last ten years.

Crawl 3: The Outer-Borough Pilgrimage (full day)

  1. Utopia Bagels, 19-11 Utopia Parkway, Whitestone — hand-rolled everything. Get there by 9am
  2. Back into Brooklyn: Bagel Hole, 400 Seventh Avenue, Park Slope — one plain, nothing on it
  3. Terrace Bagels, 222 Prospect Park West — sesame, then walk into Prospect Park

Three shops, two boroughs, and the clearest demonstration that the top bagels in NYC are not a Manhattan monopoly. Nobody doing a weekend crawl for the best bagels in New York City leaves Manhattan, and they should.

Whisper Corners: Bagel Places Nobody Lists

Whisper Corners: Bagel Places Nobody Lists
  • The shop two blocks from wherever you’re staying, at 7:15am — unironically the most underrated option in the city. New York’s floor is extraordinarily high. A nondescript corner shop with a hot tray and a guy who’s been there fifteen years will sell you a bagel at 7am that beats the famous ones at 2pm. Freshness outranks reputation by a wide margin, and that one fact undoes most published rankings of the best bagels in NYC.
  • Murray’s Sturgeon Shop, Upper West Side — not a bagel shop. A narrow appetizing counter where someone hand-slices sturgeon and sable to order, in a city that has maybe four places left doing it. Buy a quarter pound, buy bagels elsewhere, go to Riverside Park. It’s the half of the best bagels in NYC story that gets left out of every list.
  • Kossar’s at 7am on a weekday — the bialys come out and the Grand Street shop is almost empty. The single most pleasant twenty minutes available in the whole category.
  • The day-old revival trick — a stale bagel is not rubbish. Run it briefly under the tap, then straight into a 350°F oven for five to six minutes. The crust re-crisps and the interior steams back to something close to fresh. This works far better than toasting and it’s what bagel people actually do.
  • Bagel Supreme — the kind of unglamorous neighbourhood shop that explains why New Yorkers are so hard to impress on this subject. No line, no press, no interest in either.
  • The 2788 Broadway sidewalk, early — whatever you conclude about the bagels, standing outside the former Absolute at 7:30am and watching the Columbia crowd queue for a shop that technically opened six months ago is the most interesting thing happening in New York bagels right now.

What It Costs

ItemTypical 2026 price
Plain bagel, no spread1.75–2.75
Bagel with cream cheese4.50–7.00
Bagel with cream cheese at a destination shop6.50–9.00
Bagel, cream cheese and lox16–24
Russ & Daughters signature sandwich20–28
Bacon, egg and cheese on a bagel7–11
Baker’s dozen (13)22–36
Quarter pound of hand-sliced Nova18–30

Practical notes:

  • Best time: 7:00–9:00am any day. Weekend lines at Apollo, Ess-a-Bagel and Russ & Daughters start before opening
  • Worst time: after 2pm, anywhere. Buy for tomorrow and revive it instead
  • Apollo sells out. Not an exaggeration — go in the first hour
  • Freezing works. Slice before freezing, then straight from freezer to oven. Do not microwave
  • Dozen to go: most shops will bag a dozen faster than a single sandwich. If you’re feeding people, order the dozen
  • Cash: carry $20. Several shops were cash-only until very recently

The Short List

Five lines, and the rest of this page is commentary on them.

  • One bagel, one morning: Ess-a-Bagel, 831 Third Avenue, before 9am. Everything, scallion, not toasted
  • The new school: Apollo Bagels, 242 East 10th Street. First hour or not at all
  • The best thing on a bagel: Russ & Daughters, 179 East Houston Street
  • The thing you’ve never had: an onion bialy at Kossar’s, 367 Grand Street
  • The purist’s pick: Bagel Hole, 400 Seventh Avenue, Park Slope. Plain, nothing on it

Everything else here is a variation. The argument over the best bagels in NYC will keep running, partly because the shops keep changing — Absolute closing and reopening under two different names inside fifteen months is the proof of that.

What I’d actually tell you, after eleven years of weekday mornings: stop chasing the ranking. The best bagels in New York City are whichever ones came out of an oven forty minutes before you got there. Find the shop nearest where you’re sleeping, go at seven, and ask what just came out.

Eat it on the street. Don’t toast it. Get a second one for later.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best bagel in NYC?

Ess-a-Bagel (831 Third Avenue) is the most defensible single answer, with Apollo Bagels as the strongest newer challenger and Utopia Bagels the best on technique. It depends on what you want: classic chew, crust and fermentation, hand-rolling, or toppings (Russ & Daughters).

What happened to Absolute Bagels?

The Health Department shut it down in December 2024 after 67 violations. The storefront reopened in December 2025 as New Absolute Bagels under a new owner, then was renamed 2788 Bagels in March 2026. It’s open, but it’s not the same business.

Is it true that NYC water makes the bagels better?

Only slightly. The water’s low mineral content affects gluten a little, but technique matters far more. Long cold fermentation, hand-rolling, boiling in malted water and selling within two hours are what count.

Should I get my bagel toasted?

Not if it’s fresh, and some top shops like Murray’s and Ess-a-Bagel refuse to toast. Toasting fixes staleness, so a day-old bagel should be toasted, or run under the tap and baked at 350°F for five minutes.

What’s the difference between a bagel and a bialy?

A bagel is boiled then baked and has a hole; a bialy is only baked and has an onion-filled depression. Bialys are drier, chewier and more savoury, and Kossar’s (open since 1936) is the best place to try one.

How much does a bagel cost in NYC?

A plain bagel runs $1.75 to $2.75, and with cream cheese it’s $4.50 to $9.00 depending on the shop. Lox sandwiches run $16 to $28, and a baker’s dozen (thirteen) costs $22 to $36.

What are the best bagels in NYC near Times Square?

There’s no good bagel in Times Square itself. Walk about twelve minutes to H&H Bagels in Moynihan Train Hall, or to the hand-rolled Utopia Bagels at 120 East 34th Street.

Which borough has the best bagels in New York City?

Manhattan has the depth, with Ess-a-Bagel, Apollo, Russ & Daughters, Kossar’s and more. Queens has the best technical bagel (Utopia), and Brooklyn’s Bagel Hole is the purest in the city.

Do I need to go early to get the best NYC bagels?

Yes, it’s the most important tip. A bagel peaks for roughly ninety minutes after leaving the oven, so going at 7am instead of 11am changes the experience more than switching shops would. Apollo often sells out.

What should I order on a bagel as a first-timer?

An everything bagel with scallion cream cheese, untoasted, is the most representative order. For the classic, go plain bagel with plain cream cheese, tomato, onion and Nova lox.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *