Best Italian Food in NYC

Best Italian Food in NYC: 22 Places Across Three Different Cuisines

The best Italian food in NYC splits into three cuisines that get constantly confused with each other — Italian-American red-sauce cooking, regional Italian, and modern Italian fine dining — and the single biggest mistake visitors make is going to Manhattan’s Little Italy instead of Arthur Avenue in the Bronx. Little Italy is about three blocks of restaurants with hosts on the pavement. Arthur Avenue is a working Italian neighborhood with four butchers, two pasta makers and six bread stores inside one covered market.

Almost every best Italian food NYC ranking fails because it puts a Bronx red-sauce room founded in 1919 in the same list as an Emilia-Romagna tasting menu in the Flatiron, then tries to order them. Those are different foods with different purposes, and a person who wants Sunday gravy and a person who wants hand-rolled tortellini in brodo are not disagreeing — they’re answering different questions.

I’ve lived here eleven years and I’ll say up front which of the three I’d choose if forced: the red-sauce rooms, because they’re a genuine American cuisine with a century of history and they’re the thing New York does that nowhere else on earth does as well. But I’ll give you all three properly, with addresses and prices.

Twenty-two places, three cuisines, and one honest word about Little Italy — which is as close to a complete answer on the best Italian food in NYC as a single page gets.

Quick Answer: The Best Italian Food in NYC

If you wantGo toWhere
Red-sauce, the real thingMario’s, since 19192342 Arthur Ave, Bronx
Red-sauce, Queens editionPark Side107-01 Corona Ave, Corona
Red-sauce, glamorousCarbone181 Thompson St, Village
Emilia-Romagna pastaRezdôra27 E 20th St, Flatiron
Tuscan, walk-in friendlyVia Carota51 Grove St, West Village
Handmade pasta, BrooklynLilia567 Union Ave, Williamsburg
Pasta at lunch, BrooklynMisi329 Kent Ave, Williamsburg
Modern fine diningCafé CarmelliniFifth Avenue, NoMad
Italian-American, modernDon Angie103 Greenwich Ave
Wood-fired MediterraneanBorgo124 E 27th St
Market grazingEataly200 Fifth Ave

If you have one meal: Rezdôra, if you can get the booking. If you want the meal you’ll remember longer: the 4 train to Fordham and a long lunch on Arthur Avenue. Those are the two honest answers to the best Italian food in NYC, and they cost about the same.

The Three Italian Cuisines of New York

This framing does most of the work on the best Italian food in NYC question, so it goes first.

1. Italian-American red-sauce cooking

Chicken parmigiana, baked clams oreganata, stuffed artichoke, veal milanese, lasagna, Sunday gravy. Developed by southern Italian immigrants — mostly Neapolitan and Sicilian — adapting to American abundance: more meat, more cheese, more tomato than anything in Italy. It is not what people mean by authentic Italian food NYC, and it is not trying to be. It is not a degraded version of Italian food. It’s a separate cuisine, roughly 130 years old, New York is its capital, and it belongs at the front of any best Italian food NYC list.

Where: Arthur Avenue in the Bronx, Corona in Queens, Mulberry Street, and the old Village rooms — which hold most of the oldest best Italian restaurants in NYC.

2. Regional Italian

Cooking that commits to one region — Emilia-Romagna, Rome, Tuscany, Sicily. Shorter menus, fewer ingredients per plate, no garlic bread. This is the category that has transformed best Italian food NYC rankings in the last decade.

Where: Flatiron, the West Village, Williamsburg.

3. Modern Italian fine dining

Tasting menus and technique-forward cooking that uses Italian tradition as a starting point rather than a rulebook. It’s the thinnest of the three categories and the top of the best Italian food NYC market.

Where: Midtown, NoMad, the Village.

The practical upshot: before you pick a restaurant, pick a cuisine. Most disappointment with the best Italian food in New York City comes from ordering category one at a category two restaurant, or vice versa. A Roman trattoria will not make you chicken parm, and a Bronx red-sauce room’s cacio e pepe will not be the best you’ve had.

Read This First: Little Italy, Arthur Avenue, and One Michelin Correction

Manhattan’s Little Italy is a historical district rather than a living neighborhood, and it is not where the best Italian food in New York City is. It’s now roughly three blocks of Mulberry Street — the restaurants listed for it sit between about 108 and 165 Mulberry Street — surrounded on all sides by Chinatown and Nolita. The pastry shops are genuinely good, the street is pleasant, and the restaurants are mostly built on foot traffic.

Arthur Avenue in the Belmont section of the Bronx is the real one. Known as the Little Italy of the Bronx, it holds Italian-American food shops, restaurants, housewares stores and the covered Arthur Avenue Retail Market, whose vendors alone include nine restaurants, five pastry shops, four butchers, two pasta makers, six bread stores, three pork stores, five gourmet delicatessens, two fish markets, three coffee shops and an Italian wine shop. Parking is easy, which in this city is its own argument.

If you are deciding between the two for the best Italian food NYC offers, it is not close. Go to the Bronx.

One correction worth making: Don Angie is frequently described as Michelin-starred, and it is not. It won one star in 2021 and lost it in 2023. It’s still an excellent restaurant and it’s on this list — but guides and round-ups that still call it starred are out of date. The city’s Michelin-recognised Italian cooking sits elsewhere, including at Rezdôra, which held a star from 2021 through 2025 alongside a three-star rating from the New York Times.

Italian-American Red Sauce: The Best Italian Restaurants in NYC for Sunday Gravy

This is my category, and my pick for the best Italian food in NYC. Big portions, old rooms, families at the next table, a waiter who has worked there thirty years.

Italian-American Red Sauce: The Best Italian Restaurants in NYC for Sunday Gravy

1. Mario’s — 2342 Arthur Avenue, Bronx

Founded in 1919 as G. Migliucci Vera Pizzeria and run by the same family for four generations. The Migliuccis started it — one account traces the business back to Harlem’s 114th Street in 1915 — and Regina Migliucci DelFino took over after her father Joseph died in 2020. The main dining room seats 120 after expansions in the 1940s and 1980.

The James Beard Foundation named it an America’s Classic in 2000. A fourth-season episode of The Sopranos was filmed here, which The Guardian once called “more valuable than a Michelin star” — and for a room like this, it probably is.

What to order: octopus salad, striped bass Marechiare, potato gnocchi, and anything in the tomato-and-onion sauce — the oldest continuously served best Italian food NYC menu on this page. Neapolitan-style dishes have been on this menu since the 1930s.

2. Park Side — 107-01 Corona Avenue, Corona, Queens

Forty-plus years, three generations, valet parking, and the best stuffed artichoke in the city. Park Side is the Queens equivalent of Mario’s — an Italian landmark in Corona that locals and celebrities have used interchangeably for decades, with generous portions and a proper banquet operation for parties.

Hours: Monday to Saturday 12:00pm to 10:00pm, Sunday 1:00pm to 10:00pm. Lunch and dinner seven days.

What to order: stuffed artichoke, baked clams oreganata, rigatoni amatriciana, eggplant parmigiana, the seafood combination. The Colorado rack of lamb if someone else is paying.

One more reason to come to Corona: the Lemon Ice King of Corona is a few minutes away, selling Italian ices in a few dozen flavours from a corner that has barely changed in decades. Cash, no seats, and the correct end to this meal.

Park Side — 107-01 Corona Avenue, Corona, Queens

3. Carbone — 181 Thompson Street, Greenwich Village

Red-sauce cooking turned into theatre, and the hardest reservation among the best Italian restaurants in NYC. Major Food Group — Mario Carbone, Rich Torrisi and Jeff Zalaznick — built it in the old Rocco space with mid-century New York and 1960s Italian styling, captains in burgundy dinner jackets, and tableside service.

Lunch Tuesday to Sunday 11:30am–2:00pm; dinner daily 5:00pm–11:30pm. There’s a dress code — no shorts, open-toed shoes or tank tops — and corkage is $110 per 750ml bottle or $190 per magnum, which tells you what kind of room it is.

Is it the best Italian food NYC has? No. Is it one of the two or three most enjoyable Italian meals in the city? Yes. Those are different claims and the restaurant knows it.

4. Emilio’s Ballato — Houston Street, Nolita

A small room with a famously selective door and a wall of photographs. Emilio Vitolo’s restaurant has been serving southern Italian-American food on East Houston for decades, and getting a table is a matter of turning up and being patient rather than booking cleverly. The room is dark, the portions are large, the walls are covered in signed pictures, and it’s a best Italian food NYC fixture that has never advertised.

Go early, go on a weekday, and don’t be in a hurry.

5. Monte’s Trattoria — Greenwich Village

One of the oldest Italian restaurants in the Village, and almost nobody under forty has been. Pietro Mosconi’s trattoria on MacDougal Street area does the full old-school repertoire in a room that hasn’t chased any trend in thirty years. Among the best Italian restaurants in NYC for anyone who finds Carbone exhausting and wants the same food without the performance.

Monte's Trattoria — Greenwich Village

6. The Mulberry Street rooms — Little Italy

Da Nico, Il Cortile, Pellegrino’s, Amici II, Paesano, Il Palazzo and the rest, between roughly 108 and 165 Mulberry Street. Quality varies and these restaurants are honest about what they are: large menus, red sauce, outdoor tables, tourists. None of them are chasing the best Italian food in NYC title.

Go for a plate of pasta and a carafe of house red at an outdoor table on a warm evening, and go to La Bella Ferrara or one of the other pastry shops for cannoli afterwards. Just don’t expect this to be the best Italian food in New York City, because it isn’t trying to be.

Regional Italian: Where the Best Italian Food NYC Has Actually Moved

The last decade’s big change in the best Italian food in NYC. These kitchens pick one region and stay there.

7. Rezdôra — 27 East 20th Street, Flatiron

Emilia-Romagna, and the most technically accomplished pasta among the best Italian restaurants in NYC. Stefano Secchi, with partner David Switzer, cooks the food of the region that gave the world tortellini, tagliatelle, prosciutto di Parma and Parmigiano-Reggiano. The name means “the woman who rolls pasta” in the local dialect, which is the whole authentic Italian food NYC thesis in three words.

Michelin star holder from 2021 through 2025, plus three stars from the New York Times. The pasta tasting is the order. Book the moment reservations drop.

If one restaurant has to stand for the best Italian food in New York City on pure cooking, it’s this one.

8. Roscioli — Greenwich Village

The Roman institution, transplanted. Roscioli has been a salumeria, bakery and wine operation in Rome for generations, and its New York outpost brings the same model — cured meats and cheese flown in, carbonara and cacio e pepe cooked properly, a wine list of real seriousness.

Why it matters for anyone hunting authentic Italian food NYC: Roman pasta is four dishes — carbonara, cacio e pepe, amatriciana, gricia — and they’re defined by what they leave out. No cream in carbonara. No garlic in cacio e pepe. This is the clearest demonstration of how far the best Italian food in New York City has come in fifteen years.

Reservations are hard. The counter is the better seat.

Roscioli — Greenwich Village

9. Via Carota — 51 Grove Street, West Village

Tuscan, seasonal, and the rare great restaurant that takes walk-ins. Rita Sodi and Jody Williams — winners of the 2019 James Beard Award for Best Chefs, New York City — run a menu inspired by Sodi’s years at a villa near Florence, and it’s the easiest authentic Italian food NYC table to actually get.

Open Monday to Thursday 11:00am–11:00pm and Friday to Sunday 10:00am–11:00pm. Resy for bookings, and the site says walk-ins are always welcome, which in a restaurant this good is close to a public service.

What to order: the insalata verde, which sounds absurd as a recommendation until you have it; grilled octopus; fried rabbit; the whole chicken in the iron skillet.

10. Borgo — 124 East 27th Street

A Mediterranean trattoria built around seasonal wood-fired cooking. Jordan Frosolone leads the kitchen with Elijah Tarlow as chef de cuisine, and the format is the useful part: open seven days with lunch 11:30am–2:30pm, an aperitivo service 2:30–5:15pm, dinner 5:15–10:30pm and the bar running 11:30am–10:30pm.

That aperitivo window is genuinely rare in this city and it’s the answer for anyone who wants a snack and a drink at 4pm, or carbs before a curtain.

11. Niche Niche — Nolita

A wine-pairing dinner rather than a restaurant. Niche Niche runs communal, set-menu dinners built around a single producer or region, with each course poured to match. You book a seat rather than a table.

It’s the most interesting way in the city to drink Italian wine seriously without building a $400 tasting around it, and it’s a genuinely good first date for people who like talking to strangers.

Modern Italian Fine Dining

12. Café Carmellini — Fifth Avenue, NoMad

Andrew Carmellini’s grandest room, doing modern Italian and French cooking with a classic New York sensibility. Carmellini is a James Beard Award winner, and this is the most formal Italian-leaning dining room to open in Manhattan in years — inside the Fifth Avenue Hotel, with a Champagne brunch service.

For anyone searching for the best Italian restaurants in NYC on Fifth Avenue, this is the answer at the top of the market, and Eataly at 200 Fifth Avenue is the answer at the other end.

Café Carmellini — Fifth Avenue, NoMad

13. Don Angie — 103 Greenwich Avenue, West Village

Italian-American cooking rebuilt with fine-dining technique, open since 2017. Angie Rito and Scott Tacinelli take the red-sauce canon and reconstruct it — the lasagna for two is the dish people book months ahead for, a spiral of pasta rather than layers.

As noted above: it held a Michelin star from 2021 and lost it in 2023. That changes nothing about the cooking and everything about the guides that haven’t updated. It remains a fixture of the best Italian food in New York City and the clearest bridge between category one and category three.

The Pasta Specialists

The Pasta Specialists

14. Lilia — 567 Union Avenue, Williamsburg

Missy Robbins’ restaurant, the reason Williamsburg became a pasta destination, and the best Italian restaurants in NYC entry furthest from Manhattan. Handmade pastas, wood-fired seafood, Italian cocktails, in a converted auto-body shop at the corner of North 10th and Union.

Open 5:00–9:30pm Monday to Thursday and 4:00–9:30pm Friday to Sunday. Resy, or email the restaurant. It is one of the hardest bookings in Brooklyn and has been for years.

15. Misi — 329 Kent Avenue, South Williamsburg

Lilia’s sibling, and much easier to get into — plus it does lunch. Handmade pasta and vegetable antipasti, with the pasta counter visible from the room.

Dinner Monday to Thursday 5:00–9:30pm; lunch Friday to Sunday 11:30am–2:30pm; dinner Friday to Sunday 4:30–9:30pm. That weekend lunch is the best Italian food NYC serves at midday and far less contested than dinner.

Misi — 329 Kent Avenue, South Williamsburg

16. The Arthur Avenue pasta makers — Bronx

Two pasta makers operate inside the Arthur Avenue Retail Market alone, selling fresh sheets, ravioli, tortellini and gnocchi by weight. If you’re cooking rather than eating out, this is the single best stop for authentic Italian food NYC home cooks can get, and it costs a fraction of a restaurant plate.

Italian Markets, Bakeries and Groceries

17. Eataly — 200 Fifth Avenue, Flatiron (plus Downtown and SoHo)

An Italian marketplace with restaurants, counters, cafés and a wine shop under one roof, open daily 7:00am to 11:00pm — and a shortcut past the best Italian restaurants in NYC booking problem. It’s large, it’s busy, and it’s a genuinely useful entry point to the best Italian food in NYC — a pasta counter, a cheese counter, a salumeria, a fresh mozzarella operation and several sit-down restaurants.

How to use it: go before 11am or after 8pm, eat at a counter rather than booking a restaurant, and buy things to take home. The ground-floor market is better value than the dining rooms.

18. The Arthur Avenue Retail Market — Bronx

Covered, year-round, and the best authentic Italian food NYC grocery shopping there is. Four butchers, three pork stores, six bread stores, five pastry shops, two fish markets, five delicatessens, three coffee shops and an Italian wine shop, plus nine restaurants inside.

Buy bread, cheese, olives and a pork store’s sausage, then eat lunch at Mario’s. That’s the day, and it’s the best Italian food in NYC for under $50 a head.

The Arthur Avenue Retail Market — Bronx

19. The Little Italy pastry shops — Mulberry Street

Where Little Italy is genuinely excellent. Cannoli filled to order — not pre-filled, which goes soggy — plus sfogliatella, pignoli cookies, rainbow cookies, tiramisu and espresso. $4 to $9, worth the trip even when you eat dinner elsewhere, and the one piece of the best Italian food in New York City that Little Italy still owns outright.

One ordering note: ask for the cannoli to be filled when you order. If they hand you one from a tray, it’s been sitting.

Italian Wine: How to Order It Here

An under-covered part of eating Italian in this city, and the fastest way to make a cheap meal feel expensive.

The three bottles that work almost anywhere:

  • Chianti Classico — Tuscan sangiovese, sour-cherry and tomato-leaf notes, and the single best pairing for red sauce ever devised. If a red-sauce room has one good bottle, it’s this
  • Lambrusco — the dry, lightly sparkling red from Emilia-Romagna. Chilled, it cuts through prosciutto, parmesan and anything fried. Dismissed for decades on the strength of the sweet export version
  • Nebbiolo — the grape behind Barolo and Barbaresco, and the thing to order with braised meat. A plain Langhe Nebbiolo gets you most of the character at a third of the price
Italian Wine: How to Order It Here

The practical rules:

  • Order by region to match the food. Emilia-Romagna food with Emilia-Romagna wine, Roman pasta with a Lazio white. Regional restaurants build their lists this way on purpose
  • The house carafe at a red-sauce room is the right call. It’s made to go with that sauce and it costs $9 a glass rather than $22
  • Ask for something you can’t pronounce. Italy has several hundred commercially grown grape varieties, and the list’s interesting half is the part nobody orders
  • A white with seafood pasta, every time. Vermentino, Greco di Tufo, Soave
  • Pinot grigio deserves better than its reputation — the Alto Adige versions are precise and bone-dry, nothing like the supermarket style
  • Niche Niche builds whole dinners around one producer, which is the cheapest way in the city to drink seriously and learn something

Italian wine bars cluster in the West Village, Nolita and Williamsburg, and most will pour you three tastes before you commit. That willingness is the clearest marker of an authentic Italian food NYC operation: a serious list is never a locked menu.

Best Italian Food in NYC by Neighborhood

Where you areGo toCategory
Fifth Avenue / NoMadCafé Carmellini; Eataly at 200 FifthFine dining; market
FlatironRezdôra, 27 E 20th; Borgo, 124 E 27thEmilia-Romagna; Mediterranean
East 50s / Midtown EastThe old-school rooms off Lexington and SecondRed sauce, business lunch
Greenwich VillageCarbone, 181 Thompson; Monte’s; RoscioliRed sauce; regional Roman
West VillageVia Carota, 51 Grove; Don Angie, 103 GreenwichTuscan; modern Italian-American
Nolita / Little ItalyEmilio’s Ballato; Niche Niche; Mulberry StRed sauce; wine dinners
Downtown / FiDiEataly NYC DowntownMarket, quick
SoHoEataly NYC SoHoMarket
WilliamsburgLilia, 567 Union; Misi, 329 KentPasta
Corona, QueensPark Side; Lemon Ice KingRed sauce; Italian ice
Arthur Avenue, BronxMario’s, 2342 Arthur Ave; the Retail MarketRed sauce; groceries

For downtown: Carbone, Roscioli, Via Carota, Don Angie, Emilio’s Ballato and Niche Niche are all below 14th Street, which makes downtown the densest area for the best Italian food in New York City across all three cuisines.

For the East 50s: this stretch is thick with old-school Italian rooms that run on expense accounts and regulars. They’re rarely written up and they’re rarely bad — the format is a long menu, a tuxedoed waiter, a veal dish and a bottle of Chianti.

For a Date, a Birthday, Groups, Families and Valentine’s Day

The occasion questions, answered properly, because the best Italian food in NYC for a birthday is rarely the best for a first date.

For a Date, a Birthday, Groups, Families and Valentine's Day
  • Best Italian restaurants in NYC for a date night: Via Carota — small, warm, walk-ins welcome, and nothing on the menu is difficult to eat. Don Angie if you’ve planned ahead. Niche Niche if you both like wine and don’t mind a communal table. Avoid Carbone for a first date; it’s too loud to talk and too expensive to be casual.
  • For a birthday: Carbone for the spectacle, Park Side or Mario’s for a large family table at a third of the price. Both Bronx and Queens rooms do proper banquet service.
  • For large groups: Park Side in Corona and Mario’s on Arthur Avenue both have real capacity — Mario’s main dining room seats 120 — and both take party bookings. Most Manhattan regional-Italian restaurants cap out around six and will say so.
  • For families and kids: the red-sauce rooms, without question. Arthur Avenue, Corona and Mulberry Street are built for children — big tables, bread on arrival, pasta they’ll actually eat, and nobody minds noise. A tasting menu in the Flatiron is a bad idea with a seven-year-old.
  • For Valentine’s Day: book four to six weeks ahead for anything in the regional or fine-dining categories; the red-sauce rooms are easier and arguably more romantic. And consider lunch instead — Via Carota, Misi on a weekend and Borgo’s aperitivo service all give you the same kitchen with a tenth of the pressure.
  • For lunch generally: Borgo (11:30am–2:30pm), Via Carota (from 11am weekdays, 10am weekends), Misi (weekends from 11:30am), Carbone (Tuesday to Sunday 11:30am–2:00pm) and Eataly’s counters. Lunch is the most underused booking in this whole category.

Feasts and Festivals

The Feast of San Gennaro takes over Mulberry Street between Canal and Houston, plus stretches of Hester and Grand, for eleven days every September — 2026 marked its 100th annual edition, running September 17 to 27. Sausage and peppers, zeppole, enormous crowds, and free to walk in.

Ferragosto on Arthur Avenue is the Bronx’s mid-September street festival, closing Arthur Avenue for food stalls and music. Smaller, less photographed, better food. NYC Tourism carries the current dates for both each year.

What the Best Italian Food in NYC Costs

Item2026 range
Pasta, neighborhood red-sauce room18–28
Pasta, regional Italian restaurant26–38
Chicken or eggplant parmigiana24–36
Pasta tasting menu, RezdôraSet menu; book early
Dinner for two, Arthur Avenue or Corona90–140
Dinner for two, regional Italian + wine180–280
Dinner for two, Carbone300–450
Café Carmellini, per head150–250
Cannoli4–9
Italian ice, Lemon Ice King3–6
Carbone corkage$110 per bottle, $190 per magnum

Where the best Italian food in NYC value is: Arthur Avenue and Corona, by a wide margin. Two people eat extremely well for $90 to $140 in rooms with a century of history behind them, which is the best Italian food in New York City by any value measure. Where it isn’t: anywhere with a host on the pavement in Little Italy, and Carbone, which is worth doing once and is not value.

Whisper Corners

Whisper Corners
  • The Arthur Avenue Retail Market at 11am on a Saturday — the butchers are busy, the bread is warm, and you can buy a sandwich made in front of you for under $12. Then walk the street. Barely a tourist in sight.
  • Monte’s Trattoria on a Tuesday — one of the Village’s oldest Italian rooms, mostly empty mid-week, and exactly the same food it served in 1990.
  • Misi’s weekend lunch — Lilia’s sibling, far easier to book, pasta counter in view, and the single most pleasant Italian meal in Brooklyn at midday.
  • Borgo’s aperitivo, 3pm — between lunch and dinner, when a proper Italian restaurant will serve you one snack and one drink and not make it strange.
  • The Lemon Ice King of Corona — a corner in Queens selling Italian ices in dozens of flavours, cash only, no seats, no table service, no changes in decades. Get the lemon. The lemon is the point.
  • An Arthur Avenue pork store — four butchers and three dedicated pork stores operate in that market, and the sausage, soppressata and dry-cured products are better and cheaper than anything in Manhattan.
  • A cannoli filled while you watch, on Mulberry Street — the one thing Little Italy does better than anywhere, and it costs $5.

How to Order Italian in New York

  • Pick the cuisine before the restaurant. The best Italian food in NYC comes in three kinds — red sauce, regional, or fine dining. Most bad Italian meals in this city are category mismatches
  • At a regional restaurant, trust the short menu. Four pastas is an authentic Italian food NYC signal: it means they’re good at four pastas
  • No cheese on seafood pasta, and no cream in carbonara. The Roman places will quietly judge, and they’re right
  • Order the pasta as a middle course, not a main, where the menu is structured that way — antipasto, primo, secondo
  • Share the antipasti. One per two people is plenty
  • House wine at a red-sauce room is the correct order. A carafe of red, no deliberation
  • Ask what’s made in-house. It’s the most reliable authentic Italian food NYC test, and at a serious place the answer is the pasta, the bread and the mozzarella
  • Cannoli filled to order. Always
  • Book 3–4 weeks ahead for Rezdôra, Lilia, Don Angie, Carbone and Café Carmellini. Via Carota takes walk-ins; the Bronx and Queens rooms will usually seat you
  • Lunch is the hack. The same best Italian food NYC kitchens, with less pressure and lower prices

The Short List

  • One meal, best cooking: Rezdôra, 27 East 20th Street. Book the day reservations open
  • One meal you’ll remember: lunch at Mario’s, 2342 Arthur Avenue, then shop the Retail Market
  • One walk-in: Via Carota, 51 Grove Street
  • One pasta in Brooklyn: Misi’s weekend lunch, 329 Kent Avenue
  • One splurge: Café Carmellini on Fifth Avenue, or Carbone if you want the show
  • One $5 thing: a cannoli filled to order on Mulberry Street

The reason the argument about the best Italian food in NYC never settles is that it’s three arguments wearing one coat. A 1919 Bronx dining room and a 2019 Flatiron tasting menu both have a claim on the best Italian food in NYC, they are both doing their job perfectly, and they are not doing the same job.

So pick the cuisine, then pick the room. And at least once, take the 4 train to Fordham, buy bread and cheese and a pork store’s sausage, eat a long lunch where four generations of one family have been feeding people since the year after the First World War ended, and tell me Manhattan has the best Italian food in New York City.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the #1 Italian restaurant in NYC?

On pure cooking, Rezdôra (27 East 20th Street) in the Flatiron, which cooks Emilia-Romagna food and holds three New York Times stars. “Best” depends on the cuisine: Mario’s on Arthur Avenue for red sauce, and Café Carmellini for modern fine dining.

Is Little Italy worth visiting for Italian food?

For pastry, yes, since the cannoli, sfogliatella and espresso are excellent. For dinner, go to Arthur Avenue in the Bronx instead, as Manhattan’s Little Italy is now about three blocks of mostly foot-traffic restaurants.

Where is the best Italian food in NYC for red sauce?

Mario’s on Arthur Avenue in the Bronx (family-run since 1919) and Park Side in Corona, Queens, which does the city’s best stuffed artichoke. Carbone is the glamorous version at triple the price.

Are there Michelin-starred Italian restaurants in NYC?

Yes, but the list changes yearly. Rezdôra held a star from 2021 through 2025, and Don Angie lost its star in 2023, so guides calling it starred are out of date. Check the current guide before planning around a star.

What’s the best pasta in NYC?

Rezdôra for technique, Lilia and Misi for handmade pasta in Brooklyn, and Roscioli for Roman classics. Lilia is one of Brooklyn’s hardest bookings, while Misi is its easier sibling.

What are the best Italian restaurants in NYC for a date?

Via Carota in the West Village, which is small and warm and takes walk-ins. Don Angie is better if you booked weeks ahead, and you should skip Carbone for a first date as it’s too loud and performative.

Which Italian restaurants in NYC work for large groups and families?

Park Side in Corona and Mario’s on Arthur Avenue, both with proper banquet service (Mario’s main room seats 120). Red-sauce rooms suit children best, while Manhattan regional-Italian spots often cap parties at around six.

Where’s the best Italian food in NYC downtown?

Carbone, Roscioli, Monte’s, Via Carota, Don Angie and Emilio’s Ballato, all below 14th Street. That makes downtown the densest area for red sauce, Roman and modern Italian. For Fifth Avenue, try Café Carmellini or Eataly.

What’s the difference between Italian and Italian-American food?

Italian-American cooking is its own cuisine about 130 years old, shaped by Southern Italian immigrants adapting to American abundance. Dishes like chicken parmigiana and Sunday gravy are American, while regional Italian restaurants cook from one region with shorter menus.

When is the Feast of San Gennaro?

It runs eleven days each September on Mulberry Street, and the 100th edition ran September 17 to 27, 2026. It’s free to enter and crowded, and Arthur Avenue’s smaller Ferragosto festival has better food.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *