Best Pizza in NYC

Best Pizza in NYC: 18 Pies and Slices Worth the Line

The best pizza in NYC right now is Una Pizza Napoletana at 175 Orchard Street, which 50 Top Pizza ranked the No. 1 pizzeria in the United States for 2026 — but the answer changes completely depending on what format you’re after: a $3.42 corner slice, a coal-oven pie from 1905, or a Roman square cut with scissors. There is no single winner. There are about six different questions hiding inside one, and this guide answers each of them separately.

I’ve lived in New York eleven years and I eat pizza roughly four times a week, which is either a personality or a problem. What I’ve learned is that the argument about the best pizza in NYC is almost never an argument about pizza. It’s an argument about format. A person who wants a folded slice at 1am and a person who wants a 90-minute wait in Carroll Gardens for a BYOB pie are not disagreeing — they’re answering different questions.

So this is organized by question. Eighteen places, each with an address, what to order, and what it’ll cost you in time. All five boroughs are represented, because the best pizza in NYC is distributed much more evenly than Manhattan would like you to believe.

Quick Answer: The Best Pizza in NYC Right Now

If you wantGo toWhereWhat to order
The technical peakUna Pizza Napoletana175 Orchard St, LESMargherita, or the Bianca
A perfect plain sliceJoe’s Pizza7 Carmine St, VillagePlain. Fold it
The best pie in BrooklynL’Industrie Pizzeria254 S 2nd St, WilliamsburgBurrata slice
History you can tasteLombardi’s32 Spring St, NolitaOriginal Margherita
Coal-oven purityJohn’s of Bleecker Street278 Bleecker StWhole pie, no slices sold
Roman squareMama’s Too2750 Broadway, UWSPepperoni square
A 90-minute wait you’ll forgiveLucali575 Henry St, Carroll GardensThe pie. Bring wine
Late nightPrince Street Pizza27 Prince St, NolitaSpicy Spring square

If you have one meal and no patience for a line, the honest answer for the best pizza in NYC is L’Industrie — the quality is near the top and you can be eating within fifteen minutes. Of all the top pizza places in NYC, it has the best ratio of what you get to what you wait.

The Best Pizza Places in NYC, Ranked by What You Want

Rankings are fake, so here’s the one piece of outside ranking that carries actual weight, then my own list underneath it. Every entry below is a working pizzeria with a street address, because a list of the top pizza places in NYC that you can’t actually walk into is just an opinion with a headline.

The Best Pizza Places in NYC, Ranked by What You Want

50 Top Pizza — the Italian guide that assesses pizzerias worldwide with anonymous inspectors — named Una Pizza Napoletana the No. 1 pizzeria in the United States for 2026. Eleven New York City pizzerias made that national top 50, which is more than any other city:

Rank (US, 2026)PizzeriaAddress
1Una Pizza Napoletana175 Orchard St, Lower East Side
6Don Antonio309 W 50th St, Midtown
8Ribalta48 E 12th St, Greenwich Village
13Stretch Pizza331 Park Ave S, Flatiron
14Audace365 Park Ave S, Flatiron
15Pizza Secret72 Henry St, Brooklyn Heights
17Ops346 Himrod St, Bushwick
21Kesté77 Fulton St, FiDi
32Salsa Pizzeria104 E 28th St, Kips Bay
36Andrew Bellucci’s Pizzeria37-08 30th Ave, Astoria
39Pasquale Jones187 Mulberry St, Nolita

That list skews Neapolitan, because the guide is Italian and judges by Neapolitan criteria. It is a genuinely useful shortlist and it is also not the whole story — none of New York’s great slice shops appear on it, because a folded plain slice is a different object with different rules. Any honest ranking of the best pizza places in NYC has to hold both. The best NYC pizza is not one object.

Here’s how I’d actually spend your trip.

Best Pizza in NYC by the Slice

A slice is a format with its own standards: it should hold its shape when folded, the cheese should not slide off in a sheet, the underside should have char and not sog, and it should cost under $6. The citywide average for a plain slice is $3.42, with tracked prices running from $1.00 to $6.00 depending on the shop. Judged on that standard, the top pizza places in NYC for a slice are a completely different set of shops from the sit-down rooms below.

1. Joe’s Pizza — 7 Carmine Street, Greenwich Village

The reference plain slice. Joe’s has been on this corner since 1975, moved three doors down to 7 Carmine Street when its old Bleecker-and-Carmine corner building was redeveloped, and it is the slice every other slice gets measured against. Thin, pliable, properly salty sauce, cheese browned at the edges. 

Every argument about the best pizza in NYC starts from this slice, including the arguments against it. Open late, lines move fast because they sell nothing but pizza, and there are now several locations across the city.

Order the plain. Order two plains. Do not get toppings here. If someone asks you for one address for the best pizza in New York City and you only get to say one thing, say this one.

2. L’Industrie Pizzeria — 254 South 2nd Street, Williamsburg (and the West Village)

My single recommendation if you only get one. At L’Industrie, Massimo Laveglia makes a slice with a crust that’s thinner and more alive than anything else at this price, and the burrata slice — a plain slice with a ball of burrata torn over it after the bake — has become the most imitated pizza in the city. There’s a West Village location now too, which halves the wait.

The line moves. Fifteen minutes on a weekday, half an hour on a Saturday afternoon. For the ratio of quality to effort, this is the best pizza in NYC going, and it’s the address I give out most often.

2. L'Industrie Pizzeria — 254 South 2nd Street, Williamsburg (and the West Village)

3. Prince Street Pizza — 27 Prince Street, Nolita

The Spicy Spring square. Prince Street does a thick Sicilian-style square with a pepperoni cup that curls and crisps into a little bowl of fat, a fermented dough with real sourness, and a sauce that genuinely has heat. 

It’s a specific thing and they are the best at it. Open late, which makes it the default for anyone leaving a bar on Spring Street, and the only square on this list of the best pizza places in NYC that has a queue at midnight.

4. Mama’s Too — 2750 Broadway, Upper West Side

Roman-style squares, cut with scissors. Frank Tuttolomondo’s Mama’s Too does airy, deeply fermented square slices with a crisp base — closer to Rome’s pizza al taglio than to New York’s Sicilian — plus a very good round plain. 

The pepperoni square is the one. It’s the only reason most downtown people ever go to 106th Street, and it’s a sufficient one. Uptown gets written out of most best NYC pizza lists and this is the counter-argument.

5. Best Pizza — 33 Havemeyer Street, Williamsburg

Wood-fired slices from a shop that is, confusingly, named Best Pizza. The white slice is the move. It’s small, the walls are papered in pizza-box art, and it has stayed exactly as good as it was a decade ago while the neighbourhood around it changed completely. A quiet entry on the best NYC pizza lists and a permanent one.

6. 2 Bros. Pizza — multiple locations

The $1 slice is now $1.50 or more, and it is still the best cheap calorie in New York. This is not on anyone’s list of the best pizza places in NYC and it isn’t trying to be. It’s structural. It’s what the city eats at 3am. Know it exists, use it once, don’t judge the best pizza in New York City by it.

Whole-Pie Destinations: The Best Pizza in New York City for a Sit-Down Dinner

Different format, different rules. These are evening plans, not lunch stops, and several of them involve a real wait. These are also the top pizza places in NYC by any technical measure, which is why the Italian guides only ever look at this half of the city.

Whole-Pie Destinations: The Best Pizza in New York City for a Sit-Down Dinner

7. Una Pizza Napoletana — 175 Orchard Street, Lower East Side

The No. 1 pizzeria in America for 2026, and at Una Pizza Napoletana Anthony Mangieri makes every single pizza himself. That’s the whole proposition: one man, one oven, a menu of about five pizzas, naturally leavened dough fermented for a long time, and a refusal to scale. The Margherita is the measure of the place. Book ahead on OpenTable, go early in the week, and accept that the menu is short on purpose.

Whether this is the best pizza in New York City depends on what you value. Technically it is the most precise pizza in the city. It is also a $30-ish personal pie in a room with no slices and no pepperoni, which is not what everybody means by pizza.

8. Lucali — 575 Henry Street, Carroll Gardens

The hardest table in Brooklyn and worth doing once. Mark Iacono opened Lucali in 2006 in a former candy shop, and it has been near the top of every best NYC pizza list since. There are no reservations — you turn up when it opens, give your name, and come back when they call. It’s BYOB, which means the ritual is: put your name down, walk to a wine shop, drink a glass somewhere nearby, come back. Budget two hours of your evening for a 25-minute meal.

The pie itself is thin, blistered, finished with basil and a shower of grated cheese. The calzone is the sleeper order.

9. Roberta’s — 261 Moore Street, Bushwick

Wood-fired, Bushwick, and still good eighteen years in. Roberta’s Bee Sting — soppressata, chili and honey — is the pizza that launched a thousand imitations, and the original is still better than almost all of them. The garden and the whole ramshackle compound are half the point. Go for a late lunch on a weekday and you’ll walk in.

9. Roberta's — 261 Moore Street, Bushwick

10. Ops — 346 Himrod Street, Bushwick

Naturally leavened, No. 17 in America, and the most serious wine list attached to any pizza in the city. Ops ferments its dough slowly, uses very good produce, and has the discipline of a restaurant rather than a pizzeria. It’s four blocks from Roberta’s, which makes Bushwick the densest square mile for the best pizza in NYC by whole-pie standards — two of the top pizza places in NYC inside a five-minute walk.

11. Paulie Gee’s — 60 Greenpoint Avenue, Greenpoint

The best vegan pizza in the city, served without a fuss about it. Paulie Gee’s does wood-fired Neapolitan-ish pies with long absurd names, and its vegan menu — cashew ricotta, house-made vegan sausage — is good enough that non-vegans order it by accident. The slice shop around the corner on Franklin Street does a Detroit-style square.

12. Leo — 123 Havemeyer Street, Williamsburg

A wine bar that happens to make excellent pizza. Natural wine, small plates, a sourdough-ish crust with real tang. This is where you go when half the table wants pizza and half wants to sit down properly with a bottle. Not the best pizza in New York City on technique, and the best room on this page for actually talking to someone. Among the best pizza places in NYC for an actual date rather than a pilgrimage.

13. Milkflower — 34-12 31st Avenue, Astoria

Queens’ best wood-fired pie, and nobody from Manhattan ever goes. Milkflower does a proper leopard-spotted Neapolitan crust and a long list of serious toppings. Astoria is 25 minutes from Midtown on the N or W. It stays bookable on a Friday, which tells you something about how badly the outer boroughs get overlooked in the conversation about the best NYC pizza.

Milkflower — 34-12 31st Avenue, Astoria

14. Zero Otto Nove — 2357 Arthur Avenue, The Bronx

The reason to go to Arthur Avenue, and Arthur Avenue is the reason to go to the Bronx. Named for the dialling code of Salerno, it does a Neapolitan-leaning pie — the Riccardo, with butternut squash, smoked mozzarella and pancetta, is the signature. Pair it with an hour in the Arthur Avenue Retail Market beforehand. The 2 or 5 train to Pelham Parkway, or Metro-North to Fordham. The Bronx gets left off almost every best NYC pizza roundup and this is the correction.

The Coal-Oven Originals: Where New York Pizza Came From

Four pizzerias still bake in coal ovens built before the Second World War. New York’s environmental rules no longer permit new coal ovens, but existing ones are grandfathered as long as the business keeps operating — which means these four are not replaceable. That’s a reason to go that has nothing to do with whether they make the best pizza in NYC by current standards. None of the four would win a blind tasting against the Bushwick rooms, and all four belong on any list of the best pizza places in NYC anyway.

15. Lombardi’s — 32 Spring Street, Nolita

Lombardi’s calls itself America’s first pizzeria, with Gennaro Lombardi making pizza here from 1905. The coal oven, the sauce, the thin crackling base. Service is brisk and touristed, the room is loud, and the pie is better than its reputation among New Yorkers who’ve decided it’s for visitors. Open 11:30am to 10pm Sunday through Thursday, until midnight Friday and Saturday.

Order the Original Margherita. Skip the add-ons.

16. John’s of Bleecker Street — 278 Bleecker Street, Greenwich Village

Whole pies only — at John’s the sign that says “no slices” is not a suggestion. Coal-fired brick oven running around 850°F, wooden booths carved with decades of initials, and a tomato-pie style with a crust that shatters. Documents place its opening at 1915 under Filippo Milone, earlier than the long-assumed 1929 date under John Sasso. Cash only until 2016, cards now.

This is the one I send people to when they say they want the real thing, and the one I’d defend hardest as the best pizza in New York City on grounds other than technique.

17. Totonno’s — 1524 Neptune Avenue, Coney Island

Opened 1924 by Antonio “Totonno” Pero, who learned the trade at Lombardi’s. A coal brick oven, a tiny room, a pie that tastes like it predates the idea of a pizza chain. It has survived a 2009 fire, Hurricane Sandy in 2012, and a pandemic closure, and its owners began looking for a buyer in 2024. 

As of now it operates weekends only, Saturday and Sunday, noon to 5:30pm, takeout only — so check the pizzeria’s own site or call 718-372-8606 before making the trip to Coney Island. When it’s open, it’s one of the four or five most interesting pizzas in the city, and the only one on this list of top pizza places in NYC that you eat standing on a Coney Island sidewalk.

Totonno's — 1524 Neptune Avenue, Coney Island

18. Patsy’s Pizzeria — 2287 First Avenue, East Harlem

The original 1933 location, and arguably where the New York slice was invented. Pasquale “Patsy” Lancieri opened it in East Harlem and the business claims to have originated selling pizza by the slice — the practice that defined the entire city’s relationship with the food. The coal oven is still there. Note that the name was franchised out and there are a dozen Patsy’s locations now; the East Harlem one is the one that matters, and it’s the only one with the coal oven.

A thing worth knowing: Patsy Grimaldi, of Grimaldi’s and later Juliana’s in Brooklyn Heights, is a different person from a different family. Both are good. They are not related, and confusing the two is the most common error in writing about the best pizza in New York City.

Top Pizza Places in NYC by Neighborhood

If you’re deciding where to eat based on where you already are, this is the practical version of the list.

Top Pizza Places in NYC by Neighborhood
NeighborhoodGo hereFormat
Greenwich VillageJoe’s Pizza; John’s of Bleecker StreetSlice; whole pie
Lower East SideUna Pizza NapoletanaWhole pie, book ahead
Nolita / Little ItalyPrince Street Pizza; Lombardi’s; Pasquale JonesSquare; coal oven; whole pie
Upper West SideMama’s TooRoman square
MidtownDon Antonio (309 W 50th St)Neapolitan, No. 6 in the US
FlatironStretch Pizza; AudaceWhole pie
Financial DistrictKesté (77 Fulton St)Neapolitan
WilliamsburgL’Industrie; Best Pizza; LeoSlice; slice; wine-bar pie
BushwickOps; Roberta’sNatural-wine pie; wood-fired
GreenpointPaulie Gee’sWood-fired, best vegan
Carroll GardensLucaliWhole pie, no reservations
Brooklyn HeightsPizza Secret (72 Henry St)Neapolitan, No. 15 in the US
Coney IslandTotonno’sCoal oven, Sat/Sun takeout
MidwoodDi FaraSlice and pie
AstoriaMilkflower; Andrew Bellucci’sWood-fired; Neapolitan
Arthur Avenue, BronxZero Otto NoveNeapolitan-leaning

Brooklyn has the deepest bench by a clear margin. If you’re staying in Manhattan and want the top pizza places in NYC in one night, take the L train to Williamsburg and walk. Three of my picks for the best pizza in NYC sit within eight blocks of the Bedford Avenue stop.

NYC Pizza Styles, Explained

Most disagreements about the best pizza in New York City are people comparing different styles and not realising it. The top pizza places in NYC are spread across eight distinct formats, and a Neapolitan pie and a folded slice are not even trying to do the same job.

StyleWhat it isWhere to try it
New York sliceThin, wide, foldable, low-moisture mozzarella, sold by the sliceJoe’s Pizza, L’Industrie
Neapolitan60–90 second bake, soft wet centre, fresh mozzarella, eaten with a knife and forkUna Pizza Napoletana, Kesté, Don Antonio
Coal-oven / tomato pie850°F coal heat, blistered and crackling, sauce-forwardJohn’s of Bleecker, Totonno’s, Lombardi’s
SicilianThick rectangular pan pie, airy crumb, often sold as a square slicePrince Street Pizza
Roman al taglioVery long fermentation, crisp base, light interior, cut with scissorsMama’s Too
GrandmaThin rectangular pan pie, sauce on top of cheese, olive-oil-rich baseCorner shops citywide, especially in Queens
DetroitDeep pan, cheese taken to the edge so it caramelises against the metalPaulie Gee’s Slice Shop, Greenpoint
Bar pieSmall, cracker-thin, charred at the edge, meant to be eaten with a drinkScattered, West Village and New Jersey

The thing that actually unites the best NYC pizza across styles is dough time. Every place on this list ferments its dough for at least 24 hours, most of them longer, and that cold fermentation is doing more for the flavour than any topping.

One technical note worth knowing: New York’s slice shops almost universally use low-moisture mozzarella, often from Liuzzi, because fresh mozzarella releases too much water to survive a reheat. Neapolitan places use fresh. That single choice explains most of the texture difference between a slice and a sit-down pie, and it’s why asking which is better is the wrong question.

Best NYC Pizza by Style and Situation

  • Best New York–style slice: L’Industrie Pizzeria, Williamsburg
  • Best plain slice: Joe’s Pizza, 7 Carmine Street
  • Best Neapolitan pizza in NYC: Una Pizza Napoletana, 175 Orchard Street
  • Best Sicilian square: Prince Street Pizza, 27 Prince Street
  • Best Roman square: Mama’s Too, 2750 Broadway
  • Best coal-oven pie: John’s of Bleecker Street, 278 Bleecker Street
  • Best vegan pizza: Paulie Gee’s, 60 Greenpoint Avenue
  • Best pizza in the Bronx: Zero Otto Nove, Arthur Avenue
  • Best pizza in Queens: Milkflower, Astoria
  • Best pizza in Staten Island: Denino’s, Port Richmond — thin, crisp, and the one reason most non-residents take the free ferry
  • Best late-night pizza: Prince Street Pizza, or any corner slice shop on Second Avenue
  • Best cheap slice: your nearest corner shop. The citywide average is $3.42
  • Best pizza for a date: Leo, Williamsburg
  • Best pizza for a group of eight: Roberta’s, Bushwick
  • Best pizza with a cocktail: Rubirosa, 235 Mulberry Street

If you want one line that answers the question for most people: for a slice it’s L’Industrie, for a pie it’s Una Pizza Napoletana, and for the history it’s John’s of Bleecker Street. Those three are the shortest honest answer to the best pizza in NYC, and between them they cover every format the best pizza places in NYC are judged on.

Three NYC Pizza Crawl Itineraries

Split a slice at each stop. Four slices is a meal; four whole pies is a medical event. Each route below strings together three or four of the best pizza places in NYC on foot or one subway line.

Crawl 1: The Village Classics (2.5 hours, walkable)

  1. Joe’s Pizza, 7 Carmine Street — one plain, standing up
  2. John’s of Bleecker Street, 278 Bleecker Street — a small pie, split four ways
  3. Walk east through Washington Square
  4. Una Pizza Napoletana, 175 Orchard Street — book this one, it’s the finish

About 1.8 miles total. Start at 4pm so the Una reservation lands at 6:30pm. This is the densest concentration of the best pizza in New York City in any one walkable stretch.

Crawl 2: Brooklyn, The Real One (3 hours)

  1. L’Industrie Pizzeria, 254 South 2nd Street — burrata slice and a plain
  2. Best Pizza, 33 Havemeyer Street — the white slice, six minutes’ walk
  3. Leo, 123 Havemeyer Street — a glass of wine and one pie, sitting down
  4. L train one stop to Bushwick: Ops, 346 Himrod Street, or Roberta’s, 261 Moore Street

This is the single best use of an afternoon for anyone who wants to understand the best pizza places in NYC as they currently stand, rather than as they stood in 1960.

Crawl 3: The Coal-Oven Pilgrimage (full day, two boroughs)

  1. Patsy’s, 2287 First Avenue, East Harlem — where the slice may have been invented
  2. 6 train down to Lombardi’s, 32 Spring Street — the Original Margherita
  3. John’s of Bleecker Street, 278 Bleecker Street — whole pie only
  4. Saturday or Sunday only, before 5:30pm: the D, F, N or Q to Totonno’s at 1524 Neptune Avenue, Coney Island

Four coal ovens, all pre-war, in one day — the entire origin story of the best pizza in NYC in about nine hours. Nobody does this and everybody should.

Whisper Corners: Pizza Nobody Puts on the List

These are the places I eat at when I’m not researching anything. None of them will ever top a ranking.

Whisper Corners: Pizza Nobody Puts on the List
  • Di Fara, 1424 Avenue J, Midwood — Domenico DeMarco opened it in 1965 and made every pie himself at around 800°F in a 15-seat room until his death in 2022. It is a 50-minute subway ride on the Q to Avenue J, the wait has historically run an hour or more, and the pie is finished with scissored basil and a pour of olive oil. It is not what it was when he was alive. It is still a pilgrimage, and it is the single most atmospheric room on this page.
  • The slice shop closest to wherever you’re staying — unironically. New York’s floor is extraordinarily high. A random corner shop with a hot case and a guy who’s worked there twenty years will give you a $3.50 slice better than the best pizza in most American cities. The top pizza places in NYC get the headlines; the median shop is the actual achievement. Use it twice a day.
  • Rubirosa, 235 Mulberry Street — thin vodka-sauce pie, a Staten Island family recipe transplanted to Nolita, and the only pizza on this page that works as a late dinner with a cocktail. Long wait, no reservations for small parties.
  • Arthur Avenue Retail Market, 2344 Arthur Avenue, Bronx — not a pizzeria. Go for bread, cheese and olives before Zero Otto Nove, and understand what this food came from. You can’t really explain the best NYC pizza without this market.
  • The 24K pizza at Industry Kitchen, 70 South Street — a $2,000 pizza on squid-ink dough with Stilton, foie gras, Ossetra caviar, truffle shavings and 24K gold leaves, with 1.5 ounces of Almas caviar available for another $700, ordered 48 hours in advance. It holds a Guinness World Record. I am not telling you to order it. I am telling you it exists, because it’s the purest expression of what happens when New York gets hold of an idea.
  • Pepe in Grani, Caiazzo, Italy — the reference point. Franco Pepe’s pizzeria in a hill town north of Naples is the thing every Neapolitan place in New York is measuring itself against, and the standard against which the best pizza in NYC is quietly judged by the chefs making it. Worth knowing the name, because when a chef here says “Caiazzo,” that’s what they mean.

What It Costs

ItemTypical 2026 price
Plain slice, corner shop$3.42 average; 1.00–6.00 range
Specialty square slice5–8
Large plain pie, neighbourhood shop24–32
Whole Neapolitan pie, sit-down22–32
Tasting-level personal pie28–38
Dinner for two with wine, pizza restaurant90–140
The 24K pizza, Industry Kitchen$2,000, 48 hours’ notice

The pizza principle is broken. For decades the price of a plain slice tracked the price of a subway ride almost exactly — the “pizza principle,” observed since the 1960s. The base subway fare is now $3.00 and the average slice is $3.42, so the slice has pulled ahead. It’s a small thing and New Yorkers are genuinely annoyed about it. It also means the cheapest version of the best pizza in NYC now costs more than getting to it.

Practical notes:

  • Cash: many of the best slice shops take cards now, but carry $20. Some still don’t
  • Reheat: always ask. A slice from the case, reheated properly, is better than a lukewarm fresh one
  • Lines: Lucali and Di Fara run an hour or more. L’Industrie, Joe’s and Prince Street move in under twenty minutes
  • Reservations: Una Pizza Napoletana, Stretch, Audace and Pasquale Jones take them. Lucali and Rubirosa don’t
  • Best time to go: 2–4pm on a weekday for anything with a line. Sunday evening for sit-down rooms
  • Closed days: several of the old coal-oven places close one or two days a week and the days change. Call

The Short List

Here is the whole thing in five lines.

  • One slice, one stop: L’Industrie Pizzeria, 254 South 2nd Street, Williamsburg
  • One pie, booked ahead: Una Pizza Napoletana, 175 Orchard Street
  • One piece of history: John’s of Bleecker Street, 278 Bleecker Street
  • One classic: Joe’s Pizza, 7 Carmine Street
  • One square: Prince Street Pizza, 27 Prince Street, or Mama’s Too on Broadway

Everything else on this page is a variation on those five, and those five are the irreducible core of the best pizza in NYC. The argument about the best pizza in NYC will keep running because it isn’t actually settleable — a folded plain slice eaten standing up on Carmine Street and a Margherita made by one man on Orchard Street are not competing for the same prize.

What I’d tell you, after eleven years of eating this food four times a week: the ceiling in New York is high and the floor is higher. The remarkable thing isn’t Una Pizza Napoletana being the best in America. It’s that there’s a shop within four blocks of wherever you’re standing, with a hot case and a guy with a long peel, selling a $3.42 slice that would be the best pizza in most cities on earth. That’s the real answer to the best pizza in New York City, and it doesn’t have a name.

Get two. Fold them. Keep walking.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best pizza in NYC?

Una Pizza Napoletana (175 Orchard Street) was ranked No. 1 in the US by 50 Top Pizza for 2026, making it the most defensible pick. For the best slice, go to L’Industrie in Williamsburg; for the most historic pizza, John’s of Bleecker Street.

Which pizzeria in New York is the oldest?

Lombardi’s (32 Spring Street) dates to 1905 and calls itself America’s first pizzeria. John’s of Bleecker Street has documents showing a 1915 opening, while Totonno’s (1924) and Patsy’s (1933) complete the coal-oven lineage.

How much is a slice of pizza in NYC?

A plain slice averages $3.42, ranging from about $1.00 to $6.00. Specialty squares or burrata slices cost $5 to $8, so the old “pizza principle” of matching the $3.00 subway fare no longer holds.

What are the best pizza places in NYC for a first-time visitor?

Try Joe’s Pizza for the slice, Lombardi’s or John’s for coal-oven history, and L’Industrie if you’ll cross into Brooklyn. Skip the Times Square pizzerias, which rely on foot traffic rather than quality.

Is Brooklyn pizza better than Manhattan pizza?

Brooklyn has the deeper bench for current quality, with L’Industrie, Lucali, Ops, Roberta’s, Paulie Gee’s and more. Manhattan holds the historic rooms like Una, Joe’s, John’s, Lombardi’s and Patsy’s. If you only have time for one borough, pick Brooklyn.

Do I need a reservation for pizza in New York?

Sit-down rooms like Una, Stretch, Audace, Ops and Pasquale Jones take bookings, so reserve two to three weeks ahead. Lucali and Rubirosa are walk-in only for small parties (often an hour-plus wait at Lucali), and slice shops are always walk-up.

What is the best pizza in New York City by the slice?

L’Industrie’s burrata slice (254 South 2nd Street) is technically the best, with Joe’s plain slice (7 Carmine Street) a close second as the classic. For squares, try Prince Street Pizza’s Spicy Spring or Mama’s Too’s Roman pepperoni.

Which NYC pizzerias made the top 50 in America?

Eleven NYC pizzerias made 50 Top Pizza’s 2026 US list, led by Una Pizza Napoletana at No. 1, more than any other American city. The list leans Neapolitan, so treat it as a shortlist for whole pies, not the best NYC pizza overall.

Is Di Fara still worth the trip?

It’s worth visiting once, for the history and the room rather than the pizza, which isn’t what it was under Domenico DeMarco (who died in 2022). It’s a 50-minute ride with a historically long wait, so with one afternoon, choose a Williamsburg or Bushwick shop instead.

Where can I get vegan or gluten-free pizza in NYC?

Paulie Gee’s (60 Greenpoint Avenue) has the city’s best vegan pizza, with cashew ricotta and house-made vegan sausage. For gluten-free, Kesté (77 Fulton Street) makes every pizza in a separate certified space, which matters for coeliacs; Ribalta also offers a GF base.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *